1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Things you need to know about the new ‘Conversations’ PM system:

    a) DO NOT REPLY TO THE NOTIFICATION EMAIL! I get them, not the intended recipient. I get a lot of them and I do not want them! It is just a notification, log into the site and reply from there.

    b) To delete old conversations use the ‘Leave conversation’ option. This is just delete by another name.
    Dismiss Notice

Holst - The Planets OP. 32

Discussion in 'classical' started by flatpopely, Apr 26, 2014.

  1. PsB

    PsB Citizen of Nowhere™

    I have 28 (Boult 1945, cleaned up CD version), 34 (Boult 1978) and 39 (Karajan VPO 1961). That's quite enough Planets for me, but I may get 2 (Osawa) as part of a big box I'm getting (prompted by reading a book of conversations of his with Murakami).
     
  2. No problem at all, BM. And I agree completely. I shudder to think of a world in which everyone had exactly the same tastes. Ugh.

    Can't you build more shelves? Or buy a bigger house?
     
  3. JTWzen

    JTWzen Member

    I've had this recording for many years, and love it, enjoy yours, let us know what you think.
     
  4. alanbeeb

    alanbeeb pfm Member

    Well I quite agree with Dutoit/Montreal being no.1. They get everything right. Including being able to hear and feel the organ contributions.

    My 2nd fave is Boult's final recording on EMI, assume that is the 1978 LPO one?

    I think I could find space on my hard drive for a modern hi-res recording that was every bit as good a performance as Dutoit/Montreal but even better sound.
     
  5. Nic Robinson

    Nic Robinson Moderator

    I love that Boult one which i bought on vinyl in the early 80s. Still a treasured record. I think of it like one's grandfather telling stories about the adventures of his youth.
     
  6. Barrymagrec

    Barrymagrec pfm Member

    Apart from recording the work five times Boult conducted the premiere and probably knew Holst better than any other conductor who has recorded the piece. This doesn`t automatically mean his recordings are the best but certainly his final recording in 1978 takes some beating, in my opinion.

    It was also his penultimate recording before retirement, made sixty years after he conducted the first performance.

    (I am a great admirer of Adrian Boult, in case anyone was wondering)
     
  7. alanbeeb

    alanbeeb pfm Member

    Me too... his Brahms 1st from 1970s is an absolute stonker.
     
  8. Nic Robinson

    Nic Robinson Moderator

    My boss had the honour of playing the solo part in Brahms' second piano concerto under him.
     
  9. Yep.

    The Dutoit/Montréal Planets has been issued four times (1987, 1998, 2004, 2008), and the sound quality in every release has been identical. It's never been remastered.

    I'd say that Decca/London have never felt the need to "improve" the sound.

    As far as better-sounding Planets recordings go, I can thoroughly recommend the one by Seiji Ozawa and the Boston Symphony Orchestra. It's fabulous. It's neither hi-res nor modern (it's from 1979), but it sounds wonderfully transparent. I wouldn't call it "better" than the Dutoit, just different.
     
  10. Buntobox

    Buntobox pfm Member

    I've known the Planets since I was about five when my mother brought home a CFP reissue of Stokowski and the LA Phil from Woolworths, priced at 12/6. I've since added Steinberg, Karajan (twice) and now Boult. Listening to the Boult 1979 recording made my eyes go wide with amazement at the performance. I'd never heard anything like it. It was like hearing the piece for the first time again. Stunning stuff!
     
  11. dadgad

    dadgad pfm Member

    Just found the Dutoit recording on Quboz for £4.99! Will make a good comparison with my old Previn version on Vinyl :)
     
  12. Excellent.

    By the way, is the Dutoit vinyl? I've only ever heard it on CD, and wonder how the vinyl mastering copes with the dynamic range (as well as the bottomless organ in Mars, Saturn, and Uranus).
     
  13. formbypc

    formbypc pfm Member

    I know I'm late to the party, but this is the version that I inherited from my Dad's collection. I only have one other on physical media.

    I must give it a spin over the holidays.
     
  14. I think you'll enjoy it.

    Here's my review of Stoki's version:

    https://petersplanets.wordpress.com/2015/01/01/stokowski-1956/
     

Share This Page