1. Things you need to know about the new ‘Conversations’ PM system:

    a) DO NOT REPLY TO THE NOTIFICATION EMAIL! I get them, not the intended recipient. I get a lot of them and I do not want them! It is just a notification, log into the site and reply from there.

    b) To delete old conversations use the ‘Leave conversation’ option. This is just delete by another name.
    Dismiss Notice

Naim NAP200 to 300

Discussion in 'audio' started by agentsmith, Jul 9, 2010.

  1. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Currently using NDAC/282/HiCap/200

    Negotiating with someone to trade up to 300.

    Good idea? Will my Harbeth M30s sing like they never sang before?
     
  2. Rico

    Rico Bloody Colonials

    it'll be a bit mulletty. I'd be recommending a supercap on the 282, getting a 252 in there... and are there some upgrades one can do to the ndac such as an XPS? before going 250 or 300.
     
  3. Peter Stockwell

    Peter Stockwell Fried Man in Paris

    I had CDX/XPS/282/Hi/200.

    I demoed various options, not a 300, with that system and it needed CDS3/555PS and the Supercap to make significant "musical" advances. If you are planning to get a 252, 552 and a PS for the NDAC in the future, and the price is right on the 300, then buy it. It's a great amp.

    OTOH if you want to stop spending loads of money, look elsewhere to naim compatible alternatives.
     
  4. Cesare

    Cesare pfm Member

    The M30s are reasonably insensitive if I remember, so maybe there will be benefit from the 300 over the 200. Certainly if it's something that you would like to own, then I can't see any downsides. Will it sound better? My guess would be yes, but your listening levels, room etc will be important so you are best to audition if you have the choice.

    Cesare
     
  5. Avonessence

    Avonessence Consistency Rapporteur

    Take a listen to the Rega Osiris amp, before making moves further up the Naim ladder.
     
  6. jackal2513

    jackal2513 pfm Member

    Surely an XPS or 252 before changing the 200 ?
     
  7. colasblue

    colasblue pfm Member

    I think another Hi Cap or an SC or a PSU for the NDac would be the more normal option.

    A less normal option would be sell the NDac/282/Hicap and get a BM dac pre R to run the 200. the 200 is a very good power amp but a bit overpriced.
     
  8. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Just at an all too brief audition at my dealer. Setup was 282/Hicap/200 Vs 282/Hicap/300, speakers were the new Proac flagship Carbon 8 which I cannot afford, source was CDX2S.

    The 200 seemed to struggle a bit to control the low bass of the largish Proac, while managed to sound very decent with that nice pair of speakers, loads of details, heard details I never heard from my Harbeth.

    But the 300 is in a totally different league driving those speakers. Controlled the low bass with a firm grip, even more details and everything tightened up.

    It was a brief audition as I was in a hurry, but it did show me that power does make a difference at least with driving complex large speakers. I need them to show me simpler 2 way speakers like my Harbeth or maybe a pair of Neat momentums.

    I did find a 2nd hand deal on the 300, it is about 50% that of the list price. But quite affordable compared to the Naim new asking price.

    I just upgraded to the 282 not long ago so I would like to hand on to it for a little while.

    Thinking about the Supercap as well but I know getting that would mean more expenditure down the line with 252 or even 552.

    Stay tuned, I may just change my mind.
     
  9. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    BTW I am using a TeddyXPS on the nDAC
     
  10. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    I am using Hicap and TReddyXPS.

    Have used Benchmark DAC1, Lavry DA11 and Weiss DAC2 previous to the nDAC. IMO the only DAC comparable to the nDAC is the Weiss. But having tried the Weiss as a pre driving the 200, I think I will stick with the Naim preamps
     
  11. gusi

    gusi pfm Member

    When looking at s/h gear you need to get the deals when they are available. So I'd take a 300 at a good price even if it mullets the rest of the system while you are waiting for a good deal on a 252.

    A more powerful amp will give you much more control over your speakers.
     
  12. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Noted. Will try to sneak it into the house when wife is not looking ....
     
  13. James

    James Lord of the Erg\o/s

    It's a bit harder to smuggle a NAP300 to replace a NAP250 unnoticed; it comes in two boxes.

    James
     
  14. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Well, with so many similar looking black boxes it is hard to tell for "laywoman"
     
  15. Uzinusa

    Uzinusa Happy Chappy

    Agentsmith, what a cracking system you've composed! Certainly your "laywoman" is a very different kettle of fish to mine ;-) If she doesn't notice boxes, what about going active and getting a 4-pack?
     
  16. jirka

    jirka pfm Member

    Tread with caution on the naim upgrade path.
    Go out and listen to the new rega gear, avi, avondale s100 ,m130,
    or the voyager which outshines the 300 .imo by a fair margin
    You will get a big suprise what is out there,
    also see trade ads on new development from avondale
    This could be the big one for 2010
    happy listening
    ps i still have naim gear but it is gathering dust,just use it if
    someone wants to compare it against my later gear
    if you are lucky to live near zenner give him a buzz ,he will put you on the correct route,
     
  17. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Thanks it's a long way from being a high end system. The wife never took notice of these black boxes, doesn't mean she approves of them either.
     
  18. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    Thanks. I have thought many times of bailing out the Naim but the exit risk is quite high. Naim has not the best value for money IMO, but they do give a consistent performance that I have lived with for years.
     
  19. Markus S

    Markus S 41 - 29

    What exit risk? Get the competition on loan, see if you like it, if yes buy, if not go for the 300.

    Btw I don't think Naim is such bad value. What I personally find less than ideal is the sheer proliferation of boxes.
     
  20. agentsmith

    agentsmith pfm Member

    I currently resides in Hong Kong and home dem is pretty much unheard of.
     

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice